From 2009 through 2022, I completed fourteen seasons of birthday card paintings. But I confess, this fall I had some trouble mustering enthusiasm for another round.

The idea to do new art using Adobe Illustrator was intriguing. I’m still a novice with the software, and enjoy learning things. Also, it could be a step toward turning card art into animation. But I know friends really like the hand-painted designs; a few have kept collections of all the ones I’ve sent. I worry that digital art won’t carry the same emotional weight.

Before diving in with both feet, I decided to try a hybrid: making my underlying geometry in Illustrator, then coloring and embellishing it with traditional paints.

1. Coloring Book Blank

“Hybrid” and “geometry” sound fancy. But there’s no way around it…

This looks like a coloring book.

2. Test Painting (“Daytime Moon?”)

I explored a couple of different approaches, trying to obscure the machine-precise stars, circles, and rays. Crosshatching was promising. And it seemed like color gradients might be helping. I wouldn’t send this experiment to someone as a birthday card — but as a piece of ephemera, I kind of like the mix-and-match aesthetic.

After a couple hours, I set the test aside.

This coloring book concept doesn’t seem like a good basis for a series. Even if crosshatching and gradients panned out, wouldn’t I need to go back into Illustrator to build additional geometries? I suppose I could just decorate this one design in different color schemes — but that seems pretty tedious.

3. Illustrator Improv

Having now built concentric stars for both Public Access Xanadu and the coloring book experiment, I felt ready to try my first real improvisation in Illustrator.

I try to treat birthday card art like visual jazz. I like how the 5×7″ picture frame can usually be filled in a single sitting… Letting the colors and forms reveal themselves moment-by-moment, with basically no advance planning.

This first improv barely merits the name. Mostly, I just added colors to the recycled stars. Plus repetitions in the background of a single element at different scales. But, oh, the colors! So rich! And there’s proof of concept here that I can build complexity. I know I can do better — but in a pinch, I’d be willing to put this image in an envelope.

Decision made. I’ll gamble on something unfamiliar but exciting. The next round of cards are going to use vector art.